Taking BoP Strategies To Scale Pt. 3: World-Class Healthcare for the World’s Poor

Submitted by Al Hammond on May 8, 2008 - 09:16.

This post is the third in a five part series on a radical new approach to scaling BoP business models, what we call a transformative sector strategy. In this segment, I describe how this strategy could transform the health sector in emerging economies.

Last Mile Health Care Delivery

Talk to people in the rural communities of southern Mexico, in the new urban communities on the southern edge of Bogota, or in almost any village in rural Africa about getting decent access to healthcare, and their answer is the same: it usually costs more to get to a clinic, a doctor's office, even a pharmacy, than the cost of the service itself. In Bogota, most of the government-supported health services are in the north of the city, such that it can cost people in these new refugee communities a day's work plus bus fare across town and back to get help. Lack of access defines part of the last mile health care dilemma, and that means distributional business models, such as franchising, can be important.

Talk to Health Stores in Kenya, an enterprise trying to staff small pharmacies with nurses, and another part of the problem becomes clear: the sheer lack of doctors, nurses, and pharmacists in emerging markets. There are not anywhere close to the number of skilled professionals needed to cover rural areas, and these health workers overwhelmingly refuse to live either in rural areas or in urban slums. So technologies, organizational models, and legal changes that enable local diagnosis and remote practice by doctors and pharmacists could play a critical role.

Still a third factor leaps out from the data in The Next 4 Billion report that shows clearly that low-income households spend between a third and a half of their out-of-pocket health care expenditures on drugs. They typically don't go to doctors or clinics or hospitals, but rather to pharmacies or some other source of medicines and seek to self-medicate. That means they often get a guess as to what's wrong with them instead of a diagnosis.

Compounding the problem are informal supply chains in many countries that sometimes provide poor quality, fake or simply expensive medicines. In the Philippines, for example, many rural people often buy drugs from a convenience store at two to three times the pharmacy price. So building a disciplined pharmaceutical supply chain that extends to most communities could help with quality and access. With onsite diagnosis and remote practice tools, it could also become a key piece of the missing infrastructure for last mile health care delivery.

Taking Good Intentions To Scale

As it happens, there are at least four instances of a franchise pharmacy model-in Kenya, Ghana, Mexico, and one state in India--that could address these problems. None of them have yet scaled, and none of them have put all the pieces together, but they show interesting strengths. As franchises, they can expand with modest capital investment, can enlist local business talent who know the communities to be served, and can use surprise audits, secret shoppers, and other well-established approaches to ensure a disciplined supply chain with no fake drugs; so part of the value proposition (and the brand) is "drugs that work."

Selling mostly or exclusively locally-produced generic medicines, these franchise pharmacies can often be the low-cost provider. Because they typically focus on the most common healthcare problems, they stock a modest range of medicines, preventive commodities, reading glasses, and similar goods - making it easier to push distribution out to more remote communities.

With an IT logistics system (deployed in Mexico, not in the others), they can ensure that they never run short of the medicines most people need-another part of value proposition. What makes such distribution platforms potentially even more valuable, however, is the advent of new diagnostic tools designed for the BOP; these include a DNA-based diagnostic tool that can detect the major fever diseases and STDs, for example. These new diagnostic tools are inexpensive, do not require electric power or refrigeration and can be operated by para-professionals, feature color-coded readouts, and give results in a few minutes at a cost of perhaps $.50 per test. Paired with a franchise pharmacy, they offer much improved targeting of medicines and, presumably, better health outcomes - as well as another line of business for the pharmacy unit.

As remote practice tools and services expand, the pharmacy platform, especially with an IT connection, may prove even more valuable, enabling not just remote supervision of the local unit by a licensed pharmacist or doctor, but also a simple x-ray or sonogram taken locally to be read at a central hospital or radiology practice while the customer waits. They would then know whether rest and medicine would take care of the problem, or a trip to a doctor or hospital is required. GE has already launched a new, portable electrocardiograph that weighs just three pounds. Add cataract screening, monitoring basic vital signs, infectious disease surveillance, and the result could be a transformation of rural health care.

At a national scale, these franchise pharmacy chains can be sizeable, profitable, businesses that create local jobs and wealth. And there is ample opportunity to replicate the model in many countries.

In my next post, I will summarize common links between the two seemingly disparate business models in the health and ICT sectors that I have discussed here and in my previous post, identifying the common business DNA that makes for a transformative sector solution.


. . . . .
Submitted by Paul Rigterink on May 9, 2008 - 11:36.
As strange as it may sound, I believe that the sale of veterinary poultry medicines at the pharmacies described in this article can dramatically increase the health of personnel at the BOP. Backyard producers value chickens for their adaptability, contributions to the family’s income and general welfare, and for insect control and fertilizers in the garden. In most family flocks, chickens scavenge plant or food residues and insects around the home. With minimal care, family flocks can hatch and raise chicks, produce high-value meat, and supply eggs. Eggs can be a particularly important source of food for children with protein malnutrition who are between six months and three years of age. Live chickens sold for meat bring a good price and a primary source of income for poor farmers. Inexpensive disease control markedly increases the survival and productivity of a family poultry flock. The following four preventive practices, given every three months, will eliminate most health problems in poultry flocks: 1) Vaccination for Newcastle disease, 2) Deworming for roundworms and tapeworms, 3) Dusting under wings for irritating external parasites such as lice, and 4) Treatment for chronic respiratory disease to increase production. BOP personnel can easily raise up to 50 healthy chickens. To feed the chickens and obtain maximum profit on a small farm, BOP personnel can use: 1) Excess and/or unusual food crops, 2) Crop residues, 3) Household refuge and 4) Scavenger feed (e.g., weeds, seeds, insects, worms, etc). Once BOP personnel have met this “from 5 to 50 challenge”, they will be ready to move-on to learn the technology of “transitional” poultry systems of 200-300 birds and finally full commercial production of 500-10,000 birds.
Submitted by Allen Hammond on May 14, 2008 - 12:18.
Paul Rigterink's comment is fascinating and adds a deep insight to the potential of micro-pharmacy model. Since agriculture is still the abiding livelihood and critical to household food budgets in rural areas, simple means of improving animal husbandry can be important. His suggestion that micro-pharmacies, a pharmaceutical distribution infrastructure, could also serve to distribute veterinary medicines and animal care knowledge makes a lot of sense to me. It also shows the value of the distribution platform—that it can be leveraged to meet other needs, and that it can boost incomes as well as save lives. —Al Hammond
Submitted by Ndiba Wairioko on August 12, 2008 - 15:19.
As interesting as the model espoused is, it still seems to be a more top down approach to the healthcare needs in the developing south. What do the communities need? we may perceive this need to be readily accessible diagnostics or indeed affordable drugs and surveys may validate our opinions, but I venture that the communities of the developing south need and aspire to the very same standards of healthcare as the west,not a de-skilled service, not a bare bones operation but the full bells and whistles which primary care physicians or nurse practitioners, an effective and efficient referral system and an efficient supply chain to ensure consumables supplies, the challenge is how to begin to implement such a system at a grass root level, to ensure its sustainability and to grow it. I venture that the true challenge is empowering communities to be more able to pay for services either by community insurance or more elaborate national social insurance schemes in order to attract services of a global standard. Communities must look for ways to retain their often very expensively trained health workers, locally, instead of training them only to loose them to the west,a major cause of staff shortages, to attempt to bypass them might be in the long run counter productive
Submitted by online doctor on August 25, 2008 - 12:56.
Remote practice tools and services are evolving not only in pharmacy but also health care. I very much agree that communities must look for ways to retain their often very expensively trained health workers, locally. However, rural communities, such as the ones mentioned in this article of southern Mexico, the southern edge of Bogota and most of Africa, must also take advantage of health professionals through telemedicine and other remote health care innovations.
Submitted by ninin on August 26, 2008 - 02:38.
I'm just wondering how many people themselves are able to reach telemedicine system in those rural communities? This is People's life we have to protect.
Submitted by Nick on August 29, 2008 - 06:54.
Check out the video on the offsite care website. It is a great example of how rural hospitals are utilizing robotic telemedicine to deliver intensivist services to patients in the ICU.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Basic HTML tags are accepted.
  • To ensure that you are human, your comment must first be previewed, then posted to the site. Please click "Preview" to see how your comment will look when posted.