Lessons from Microfinance for India’s Social Sector: An Opportunity to Avoid Pitfalls and Achieve Greater Impact
We in the nonprofit and social enterprise sectors are often too busy to invest in ourselves and our teams, to take proper rest, and crucially, to learn from the histories of our organizations, sectors and adjacent movements. I recall multiple times when an organization I was involved with was trying to solve a problem, not realizing that a solution had actually been discovered, documented and published by that very same institution years earlier. Collectively, we need to slow down a bit; as the saying goes, sometimes you need to go slow in order to then go fast.
I spent the first 30 years of my career in the microfinance movement (or “industry” as some prefer to call it), including 18 years serving as founder and leader of Grameen Foundation. We accomplished a lot, while also making many mistakes — some of which we learned from. Both the sector’s achievements and setbacks have been well documented, if often contested. My own contributions to and observations about that journey are available in my book “Small Loans, Big Dreams” which was excerpted in this article in the Stanford Social Innovation Review.
I have found it striking how many of the central lessons from the microfinance industry globally are highly relevant to the social sector in India (and beyond) today. It is my fervent hope that these hard-earned insights won’t have to be relearned — often at great expense of time, talent and money.
Below, I’ll summarize a few of the most important lessons the sector has generated.
Develop local sources of finance
Initially, many microfinance organizations in the Global South sought grants, loans and (later) equity from international sources. These proved risky, especially as the amounts grew exponentially. Managing currency risk on dollar- or euro-denominated loans and navigating the whims of investors became increasingly tricky. Over time, many practitioners learned that bringing in local donors, lenders and investors paid handsome dividends and avoided unnecessary risk, heartache and sleepless nights. I am proud that Grameen Foundation’s innovative Growth Guarantees program (initiated when I was its CEO) enticed commercial lenders to provide more than $145 million in local currency financing to leading microfinance institutions, including several in India.
Today, NGOs in India are learning the dangers of being overly reliant on foreign donations. Many are shifting to local funding sources by taking advantage of the growth in corporate social responsibility grants that are mandated by law for many Indian companies. This represents a good start, but it will be necessary to recast the relationship with corporate partners and related policymakers so that donations come over multiple years (which allows recipients time to plan and execute on realistic timelines), are shorn of unnecessary restrictions, and are focused on areas of highest need. Furthermore, fundraising from high net-worth individuals in India needs more emphasis, especially since the nation has the third most billionaires of any country in the world, according to Forbes magazine. The fundraising trainings delivered by India Leaders for the Social Sector represent a positive development in this regard.
Actively work with the public sector at all levels
For far too long, we in the microfinance sector thought that benign neglect was the ideal state of our relationship with government. They ignored us, and for the most part we ignored them. Few among us had the foresight to see that not cultivating those relationships year-in and year-out would one day come back to haunt us. When the dynamic turned against us in 2010 — due to a combination of self-inflicted wounds, (e.g., high interest rates, questionable lending decisions and overly aggressive debt collection practices) and opportunistic attacks from those threatened by microfinance — public opinion soured and the industry drew harsh regulatory scrutiny in many countries. In India, for example, the sector spent five years in crisis mode and the next decade nursing our wounds and recovering.
The headline-grabbing events of that year included the Bangladesh government harassing Professor Yunus and the Grameen Bank, the state government in Andhra Pradesh effectively outlawing private sector microfinance, and the No Pago (Non-Payment) Movement gaining steam in Nicaragua — a perfect storm of anti-microfinance efforts. A more proactive government relations approach by the microfinance sector would likely have reduced the severity of these conflicts.
The Indian NGO sector looks primed to avoid this pitfall, as many have devoted significantly greater resources to compliance efforts. This must continue. At the same time, NGOs should take advantage of the strong interest pragmatic state and local governments have in partnering with them, and they should study and apply the lessons other NGOs have learned, related to cultivating successful public sector partnerships.
Rely on well-supported skills-based volunteers, but only for those things they can do well
Once microfinance became a multi-billion dollar global industry, many organizations phased out their engagement with volunteers as they sought to professionalize their operations. The few volunteers that remained were mostly relegated to board service in nonprofit microfinance organizations, and even those roles were often ceremonial. As a result, the sector missed out on millions of potentially donated hours. Even more importantly, microfinance’s roots in civil society withered — which came back to haunt us when populist politicians attacked the industry and journalists looking for a new story to tell about microfinance piled on.
The fact that far fewer people who weren’t employed in microfinance were left to defend it made matters much worse. Grameen Foundation was an exception to this trend, launching Bankers Without Borders in 2008 with the aim of mobilizing thousands of skilled professionals to volunteer their time with microfinance organizations and, later, the broader social sector. Today, it has more than 28,000 professionals in its reserve corps, hundreds of whom are deployed each year on assignments that often span weeks in length.
Indian NGOs and their partners in the Global North have done a better job of engaging volunteers than microfinance did, but at times they have relied on them too much and for the wrong things. Furthermore, they have often not provided these volunteers with sufficient training and support.
To take an example I learned early in my career, having pro bono legal counsel is a worthwhile use of volunteer support, but if you lack in-house legal expertise, you won’t know how to get the most — or even anything of value — out of your volunteer lawyers. Distinguishing which tasks are appropriate for volunteers, and then recruiting and supporting those individuals with the necessary skills to undertake those tasks, requires a lot of up-front work — but it ultimately pays off.
Convince stakeholders to invest in monitoring and evaluation of outcomes, and leverage the insights to improve services
Too often in microfinance, we focused on measuring and reporting on outputs, such as loans disbursed and savings collected. We assumed that if these indicators were trending positively, we were having a positive impact on clients, which in many cases was true — but in some cases was not, and in other cases was only marginal. Meanwhile, many in the sector believed it was too time-consuming and expensive to develop a better understanding of who was benefitting the most from microfinance — as opposed to just treading water — and why certain clients were reaping more benefits from their loans. Quietly, some feared that those insights would underscore the need for greater product innovation and customization, which could slow down growth and reduce profits.
There were some notable exceptions to this rule, such as Grameen Bank, which invited dozens of teams of external researchers to study their performance throughout the 1980s and 1990s (including a major World Bank effort using a quasi-experimental design). Indian NGOs need to follow the leads of organizations like Pratham and AIF by investing more in internal monitoring as well as external evaluations. In some cases, this will mean making the case to initially skeptical donors that this is not a nice-to-have, but a must-have. In others, using unrestricted grants from sophisticated donors for monitoring, evaluation and learning makes sense. Used well, these investments can benefit the entire social sector’s knowledge base and reputation.
Actively engage in how evidence is communicated and interpreted
Inviting in outside researchers brings benefits, but also risks. I have written extensively about how the public relations advisers of microfinance researchers in the 2010s had a tendency to emphasize the negative in efforts to promote their studies. This spin did serious harm to the industry. Grameen Bank partially inoculated itself against this kind of blowback by requiring that the many teams of researchers that studied it had to agree to publish any rebuttal by Grameen in the same volume as the research itself.
If Indian NGOs invest more in external studies, they must take measures to influence how the public, policymakers and donors understand research findings, which are often highly technical and open to interpretation. (For instance, even a finding of solid positive impact can be characterized as underwhelming, less than promised, or even negative.) Making sure positive aspects receive sufficient coverage, and that mixed or negative results are properly contextualized, are essential and won’t happen automatically.
Balance depth and breadth of outreach, and other important tradeoffs
After early peer-reviewed research about microfinance in Bangladesh showed strong positive impact, the industry leveraged this good news and focused on achieving mass scale; however, this drive for big numbers often came at the expense of quality and customization. Achieving client-level impact was too often sacrificed for meeting big goals related to client outreach. As a result, there was insufficient experimentation in many areas of product development, among other adverse consequences. In one famous case, a pilot program where borrowers were allowed to delay their loan payments showed greater social impact, but also marginally higher default rates. Rather than extending the pilot to figure out how arrears could be reduced, it was prematurely cancelled since it was not viewed as scalable.
The Indian nonprofit sector likewise seems to be over-emphasizing scale at the expense of deeper impact and learning. This constrains its ability to truly solve problems, forcing it to nibble around their edges. One shining example of prioritizing depth of impact over scale is Ek Kadam Aur’s program to get blind children into public schools by working intensively with parents, teachers, and the youth themselves over 18 months on average. If the endgame for many NGO programs is having the public sector scale them, why not sacrifice some outreach in the service of greater per-client impact, as long as the per-client cost is kept at a level that makes sense for public administrators?
As someone who has done development work on four continents, I can say confidently that Indian NGOs are among the best in the world. Their achievements are influencing the global humanitarian agenda, even more so now that official development assistance has been cut back. They should take pride in their achievements, and I am proud to be their friend in my roles as an author, consultant and the director of the India Philanthropy Alliance.
However, in order to continue that leadership and avoid the pitfall of complacence, it’s essential to draw lessons from adjacent social sector fields, as well as from business and government. Microfinance has a vast reservoir of lessons for Indian NGOs, as they expand their good work in their home country and continue to serve as models, partners and inspiration to those who are working for the common good in other regions of the world.
Alex Counts is the executive director of the India Philanthropy Alliance and the author of four books (including “Changing the World Without Losing Your Mind“).
Photo credit: Jirsak
- Categories
- Finance



