Small Premiums, Long Term Benefits: Why Poor Women Need Microinsurance
Editor’s Note: The following Guest Post on microinsurance follows two previous entries on the same topic published recently by Staff Writer Manuel Bueno and Guest Writer Martin Herrndorf. Today’s piece explores the role of microinsurance addressing the challenges faced by women in low income communities.
* * *
Monica Kirunguru’s husband was an outgoing man, and a prominent member of his community. The couple lived together on a farm near Mount Kenya, where they worked hard to support their seven children and five grandchildren.
In August 2009, Monica’s husband was admitted to the hospital. One month later, he passed away.
Coping with the emotional shock that accompanies the death of a life partner can be staggeringly difficult. Coping with the financial shock at the same time, however, can make the situation seem unbearable. Typically, a Kenyan woman in Monica’s circumstances would have two options to cover the hospital and funeral expenses: take out a high-interest emergency loan, or approach friends and family for money.
Monica had a different luck. When her husband was admitted to the hospital, she was informed that he had bought health and life insurance two months earlier. The policy paid out USD $330 to cover hospital bills, a weekly stipend of $25 for the family’s living expenses during hospitalization (which Monica used to continue paying the children’s school fees), and $400 toward the funeral, which was attended by over 1,000 people. She’s now learning how to run the farm on her own, grateful not to be in debt.
Monica’s story is certainly the exception among poor women struck by crises. As Manuel Bueno discussed in his recent blog posting, microinsurance aims to help low-income people manage risk and reduce their vulnerability to shocks. However, it’s estimated that only three percent of the low-income people in the world’s 100 poorest countries benefit from a microinsurance product, leaving approximately two billion people unprotected. Of those two billion, more than half are women.
Making the most of women’s resources
Women comprise 70 percent of the world’s poor. They earn less than men, have less control of property, and face higher levels of physical vulnerability and violence. They are often caregivers, homemakers, and, increasingly, household resource managers and income earners. Considering this combination of vulnerability and responsibility for the welfare of their families, women have a unique and pressing need to manage risk.
Traditional risk management strategies that women use to cope with crises involve long-term sacrifices that perpetuate the cycle of poverty. For example, using business profits to deal with emergencies instead of using them for long-term investments is one of the largest barriers to growth for female entrepreneurs. Similarly, selling productive assets such as livestock or equipment sacrifices any future income from those assets. Another crisis management strategy, pulling children out of school, not only stunts children’s social and intellectual growth but also severely curtails their long-term earning potential.
Sustainable and sensitive: Designing products for women
Microinsurance offers a promising alternative for poor women to manage risk and use their assets more productively. As resource managers and caregivers, women are a natural target market for insurance companies. The challenge, however, is creating microinsurance programs that meet the needs of poor women, minimize operating costs, and keep premiums affordable – all at the same time.
Poor women have specific needs that make it difficult to design profitable insurance products. For example, many health microinsurance programs exclude pregnancy, citing the high costs caused by adverse selection. However, some schemes have successfully used innovative models to reduce costs and improve accessibility. In West Africa, a French NGO called Centre International de Développement et de Recherche (CIDR) developed a health insurance product with maternity cover. The product is sold at the village level, with all inhabitants paying an annual fee to cover all pregnant women in the village. Since participation is mandatory, adverse selection and administrative costs are minimized, allowing for an extremely affordable premium: only $0.40 per year. In Guinea, after one year, the maternity benefits covered 1,000 women.
In India, another program is meeting women’s unique needs in a sensitive, sustainable way. SEWA Bank offers its clients – all self-employed poor women – a choice of three microinsurance schemes covering death, health and assets. Like pregnancy, coverage for the entire family is another aspect of microinsurance that is important to women but is often unaffordable. Available at various price points to ensure accessibility, SEWA’s schemes provide options to cover husbands and children for a low incremental fee. All the children in a family are covered by one premium, to avoid families having to choose which of their children to insure (a choice that usually favors male children). Another innovative feature is that the insurance is integrated with SEWA’s savings accounts. Clients can use their accrued interest to pay premiums, improving accessibility and reducing administrative costs. Starting with 7,000 clients in 1992, Vimo SEWA now covers nearly 200,000 women, men and children.
The Future of microinsurance for women
Microinsurance represents a new frontier of development, and there’s much work to be done toward creating a gender-sensitive microinsurance industry. It’s crucial to understand how women combine microinsurance with existing risk management strategies, how their attitudes toward risk differ from those of men, and how microinsurance affects their rates of investment into businesses, savings behaviors, and household consumption. More information on creating gender-sensitive microinsurance can be found in a recent study published by the ILO’s Microinsurance Innovation Facility and Women’s World Banking.
As for Monica, she reports that, since her husband’s death, her friends and family have been asking her about the insurance and how she managed to avoid incurring debts or asking the community for money. Monica is spreading the good word – she now tells everyone she meets that they should buy the insurance. And, she says, she will definitely renew the policy when it lapses.